ROUND: 1
TOPIC: weak-shortcut-honesty
MODE: skill-review
SESSION: dt-weak-shortcut-honesty-20260410-api
DECISION: defer
PATCH_STATUS: none
CONTINUATION_SIGNAL: continue
NEXT_ACTION: retry consultant extraction once, then downgrade to analysis-only if it still fails
CHAT_CONTINUITY: reused
RESUME_SNIPPET: |
  ROUND: 1
  TOPIC: weak-shortcut-honesty
  MODE: skill-review
  SESSION: dt-weak-shortcut-honesty-20260410-api
  NEXT_ACTION: retry consultant extraction once, then downgrade to analysis-only if it still fails
SELF_POSITION_STATUS: compact
CONSULTANT_POSITION_STATUS: compact
SYNTHESIS_STATUS: compact
SELF_POSITION_COMPACT:
- verdict: consultant shortcut can stay honest only if compact self state is explicit
- weakness: fake consultant-bearing success would hide extraction failure
- fix: keep consultant-shaped compact output and explicit downgrade path
CONSULTANT_POSITION_COMPACT:
- consultant_verdict: extraction is weak but still recoverable for one retry
- strongest_finding: consultant-bearing shortcut must keep consultant-position shape
- proposed_fix: retry once with the narrow consultant template before downgrading
SYNTHESIS_COMPACT:
- relation: partial
- decision: defer
- next_action: retry consultant extraction once, then downgrade to analysis-only if it still fails
