term-sheet-negotiation-coach

by charlie-morrison

Install this Skill

curl -fsSL -o term-sheet-negotiation-coach.zip https://skill.seembox.com/api/v1/skills/term-sheet-negotiation-coach/download && unzip term-sheet-negotiation-coach.zip

Download term-sheet-negotiation-coach.zip

SKILL.md About

---
name: term-sheet-negotiation-coach
description: Coach a founder through reading and negotiating a venture term sheet — every economic and control term, line by line. Covers valuation (pre-money / post-money / option pool top-up out of pre-money), liquidation preference (1x non-participating standard; 2x or participating = problem; senior vs pari-passu), anti-dilution (weighted average broad-based standard; full ratchet = avoid), pro-rata, dividends, redemption rights, conversion, vesting (founder + employee), board composition (size, observer rights, independent), protective provisions (the "veto list"), drag-along / tag-along / ROFR, no-shop / exclusivity, expense reimbursement, MFN among investors, side letters, founder-secondary cash carve-outs, and the negotiation sequence (what to ask for first, what to give up last). Use when founder says "got a term sheet", "term sheet review", "negotiate term sheet", "what's reasonable in a term sheet", "investor pushing 2x preference", "ESOP top-up", "anti-dilution", "drag along", "founder vesting reset". Triggers on phrases like "term sheet", "term sheet negotiation", "liquidation preference", "anti-dilution", "ESOP top-up", "no shop", "drag along", "preferred stock", "SAFE conversion", "pre-money post-money", "investor counsel", "founder counsel", "exclusivity", "MFN".
---

# term-sheet-negotiation-coach

Coach a founder through term-sheet review and negotiation. The term sheet is the most consequential document a founder signs before legal closing — every clause maps directly to founder ownership at exit, founder control during the company's life, and founder optionality if things go sideways. Most first-time founders accept the first draft because they don't know which terms are "standard" vs "negotiable" vs "predatory". This coach walks the term sheet line by line, sets the negotiation priorities, and gives the founder the leverage map.

This is NOT legal advice and does NOT replace startup counsel. It IS the framework that lets the founder talk usefully to their attorney rather than letting the attorney drive every decision unchallenged. A founder who walks into the negotiation knowing what each clause does and which clauses to fight for gets a much better deal than one who relies entirely on counsel.

## When to engage

Trigger when the founder mentions:
- Direct: "got a term sheet", "term sheet review", "term sheet negotiation"
- Specific terms: pre-money, post-money, option pool top-up, liquidation preference, anti-dilution, pro-rata, dividends, redemption, board composition, protective provisions, drag-along, tag-along, ROFR, no-shop, exclusivity, MFN, founder vesting
- Process: "investor counsel", "founder counsel", "side letter", "term sheet draft 2"
- Problems: "investor pushing 2x preference", "they want a board seat", "they want full ratchet anti-dilution", "they want to reset my vesting"

Do not engage for: SAFE / convertible note negotiation (related — touch on briefly here but most term-sheet content is for priced rounds), specific legal-liability questions (refer to counsel), securities-compliance issues (refer to securities counsel), or pure cap-table modeling (use cap-table-management-coach for the cap-table mechanics; this skill is the negotiation playbook).

## Diagnostic sweep — before reading the term sheet

1. **Stage and round.** Pre-seed / seed / Series A / Series B+. Term sheet customs differ across stages. A Series A term sheet is much more detailed than a seed.

2. **Lead investor profile.** Tier-1 firm, mid-tier firm, individual / strategic investor. Term sheet practices vary. Tier-1 firms tend to use more standardized terms; individual / strategic investors sometimes push idiosyncratic terms.

3. **Round dynamics.**
   - Are there competing term sheets? Multiple lead investors?
   - Is the round oversubscribed?
   - How long has the lead been in process?
   - Other co-investors lined up?
   These dynamics dictate leverage.

4. **Existing cap table state.** SAFEs / notes outstanding? Existing preferred? Founder-employee vesting status? Cleanup needed before this round?

5. **Counsel.** Does founder have startup-experienced counsel (not corporate-generalist)? If not, fix this before negotiating.

6. **Founder's walk-away point.** What deal terms would make founder say "no, we'd rather not raise"? Most founders haven't thought through this; without it, they negotiate from weakness.

## The structure of a term sheet

Most VC term sheets follow a similar structure (NVCA model is the de-facto standard in the US):

### Front-matter
- Parties
- Round size, lead investor name, share class

### Economics
- Pre-money valuation
- Post-money valuation (= pre + raise)
- Price per share
- Option pool top-up (size + whether out of pre-money or post-money)
- Liquidation preference
- Conversion / mandatory conversion
- Anti-dilution
- Dividends
- Pay-to-play

### Control
- Board composition
- Voting rights
- Protective provisions (the veto list)
- Information rights
- Inspection rights

### Investor rights
- Pro-rata / right of first offer
- Drag-along
- Tag-along
- ROFR (right of first refusal)
- Co-sale rights
- Registration rights

### Closing terms
- Vesting (founder + employee)
- IP assignment
- Non-compete / non-solicit
- D&O insurance

### Process terms
- Conditions to closing
- No-shop / exclusivity
- Expense reimbursement
- Confidentiality

Walk through each section with founder lens.

## Economics — the dollar terms

### Pre-money vs post-money valuation
- Pre-money = company value before the round
- Post-money = pre-money + round amount
- Founder ownership after round = founder's pre-round shares / post-money fully diluted shares

### Option pool top-up — the biggest unspoken founder dilution
- Investors typically require ESOP to be 10-15% of post-money fully diluted
- TOP-UP COMES OUT OF PRE-MONEY — i.e., founders dilute, not investors
- Math example: $5M raise at $20M pre-money. With 5% ESOP top-up, effective pre-money is $19M. Founder dilution increases by ~5 percentage points.
- **Negotiate**: smaller top-up (only what you need for next 18 months of grants, not 10-15% across-the-board). Push back with: "We have grants budgeted at X; let's size the pool to actual need."
- **Negotiate**: top-up shared between pre-money and post-money (rare but possible)
- **Trick**: investor's "standard" 10-15% pool is often more than needed; aim for 7-10% in actual hire-plan

### Liquidation preference — what investor gets in a sale
- 1x non-participating preferred = standard. Investor gets MAX(money back, share of common-stock equivalent).
- Translates to: at exit, investor gets their money back if exit is at-or-below their investment; if exit is above, they convert and share pro-rata with common.

### Liquidation preference variations to push back on
- **2x preference**: investor gets 2x their money back before common gets anything. RARE in healthy 2024-2026 deals; signals weak company or down market. NEGOTIATE to 1x.
- **Participating preferred**: investor gets money back AND converts to common (gets their pro-rata share of remaining proceeds). Effectively double-dip. NEGOTIATE OUT.
- **Capped participating**: participating with a cap (e.g., investor gets money back + share until they've made 3x their money, then stops participating). Less bad than uncapped participating, still bad.
- **Senior vs pari-passu**: in multi-round companies, later-round investors are often "senior" (paid first), middle-round investors next, earlier-round last. Confirm: is this round senior to all prior preferred? Or pari-passu (equal priority)?

### Conversion
- Voluntary: investor can convert preferred to common at any time at the conversion ratio.
- Mandatory (auto-conversion): investor's preferred auto-converts on (a) IPO above some threshold, (b) majority preferred vote.
- Standard: 1:1 conversion ratio (1 preferred → 1 common). Conversion ratio adjusts for stock splits, etc.

### Anti-dilution
- **Weighted average broad-based**: standard. If subsequent down-round, prior investor's conversion ratio adjusts based on weighted-average formula. Mild dilution protection. Founder-friendly.
- **Weighted average narrow-based**: tighter formula (uses only common stock outstanding, not options). Slightly worse for founders.
- **Full ratchet**: subsequent down-round resets prior investor's conversion price to the new (lower) price. Devastating for founders. AVOID.
- **Carve-outs**: standard exemptions to anti-dilution (employee equity grants, conversions of SAFEs/notes, certain strategic investments). Negotiate broad carve-outs.

### Dividends
- Cumulative dividends (e.g., 8% per year, accumulate even if not paid) = bad for founders. Adds to liquidation preference at exit.
- Non-cumulative dividends (e.g., 8% if and when declared) = effectively zero in most cases.
- Standard 2024-2026: non-cumulative or zero dividends.

### Pay-to-play
- If a future round happens, existing investors must participate pro-rata or lose certain rights (anti-dilution protection, voting rights, sometimes converted to common).
- Founder-friendly: incentivizes existing investors to support down-rounds.
- Investor-unfriendly: investors push back.
- Sometimes appears in distressed / down-round contexts.

## Control — who decides what

### Board composition
- Pre-Series A: typically founder-controlled (1-3 members; founder is majority)
- Series A standard: 5-member board (2 common-elected, 2 preferred-elected, 1 independent agreed by both)
  - Common-elected: typically founders
  - Preferred-elected: investor + a co-investor or another founder-friend
  - Independent: industry expert, hand-picked but mutually agreed
- Series B+: 5-7 members; investors may push for 2 preferred seats per round
- **Negotiate**: keep board size small (5 max at Series A); ensure independent is genuinely neutral (not investor-allied); preserve common majority or 50/50 with friendly independent

### Observer rights
- Investor can have a non-voting observer attend board meetings.
- Standard for sub-lead investors. Limited downside; doesn't dilute decision-making.
- **Negotiate**: confidentiality obligations on observer; right to exclude observer from sensitive items (executive sessions).

### Protective provisions (the veto list)
- Investors get veto rights over a list of significant company actions:
  - Changing certificate of incorporation / bylaws
  - Issuing senior preferred (next-round terms)
  - Sale or merger of company (M&A)
  - IPO
  - Liquidation / dissolution
  - Borrowing > $X
  - Hiring / firing CEO
  - Annual budget approval
  - Subsidiary creation
  - Key transaction with founder / officers (related-party)
- **Negotiate**: which actions specifically, and which threshold of preferred shareholders triggers veto (majority of preferred? Each series independently? Series A only?)
- **Negotiate**: high-dollar threshold for borrowing / spending vetoes (e.g., $1M+ instead of $100K+)
- **Negotiate**: budget approval is hardest — investor approval of every annual budget is a control mechanism that lets investor block strategy. Push back; alternative is "approval not unreasonably withheld".

### Information rights
- Standard: monthly / quarterly financials, annual budget, board materials.
- Investors with substantial stakes (5%+) typically get audited financials annually.
- **Negotiate**: balance disclosure with not being a constant reporting drain. Standard rights are fine; very granular weekly reporting is unusual.

### Inspection rights
- Investor right to inspect company books, records, facilities.
- Standard.

## Investor rights — secondary deal mechanics

### Pro-rata / right of first offer
- Investor right to participate in future rounds proportional to current ownership.
- Standard for major investors.
- **Negotiate**: sunset clause (rights apply only to next 1-2 rounds, not perpetually); minimum threshold (rights only above some ownership %)

### Drag-along
- Majority can force minority (and common shareholders, including founders) to sell on agreed terms in an acquisition.
- Standard. Critical for clean exits.
- **Negotiate**: triggering threshold (51% of preferred? Majority of all shareholders? Both?)
- **Negotiate**: founder protection (drag-along requires concurrent action by majority of founders; or limited protection if exit valuation is below some threshold; founder's vested equity protected)

### Tag-along (co-sale)
- Minority can sell pro-rata if majority sells in secondary.
- Standard.
- Mostly affects founder secondary sales (employees get tag-along if founder sells without offering same to them).

### ROFR (right of first refusal)
- Company / existing shareholders get first right to buy any shares offered for sale.
- Applied to founder secondary sales typically.
- **Negotiate**: exemptions for transfers to family / estate planning / charitable; exemptions for small transactions.

### Registration rights
- Right to require company to register shares for sale in IPO / public offering.
- Demand registration: investor can demand IPO under specified conditions.
- Piggyback: investor can include shares when company files registration.
- S-3: investor can require S-3 (short form) registration after IPO.
- Standard. Negotiable: minimum demand threshold (e.g., investor with 30% can demand; not investor with 5%).

## Closing terms — vesting and IP

### Founder vesting (often the most contentious term)
- Investors typically require founder vesting on Series A.
- Standard: 4-year vest, 1-year cliff, double-trigger acceleration on change of control + termination without cause.
- **Negotiate**: credit for time already served (e.g., founder has been working for 2 years; 50% should already be vested).
- **Negotiate**: acceleration provisions (single-trigger 25-50%; double-trigger 100%).
- **Negotiate**: definition of "termination without cause" (broad enough to protect founder).
- **Push back hard on**: vesting reset (starting fresh from term sheet date for someone with years of service). This is rare and aggressive.

### Employee vesting
- New employees: 4-year vest, 1-year cliff, standard.
- Existing employees: typically retain existing vesting schedules.

### IP assignment
- Standard: founder + key employees sign IP assignment / PIIA at closing.
- Confirm: any prior IP not yet assigned to company. Get retroactive assignments before close.

### Non-compete / non-solicit
- Investors typically push for 1-2 year non-compete on founders.
- 1-year is more standard; 2-year is aggressive.
- Geographic scope: typically limited to specific geos / sectors.
- **Negotiate**: non-compete reasonable in scope and duration. Non-solicit (don't solicit employees / customers) is more enforceable than non-compete in many jurisdictions.

### D&O insurance
- Standard for board members.
- Funded post-close.

## Process terms — the negotiation mechanics

### No-shop / exclusivity
- Founder can't talk to other investors during exclusivity period.
- Standard 30-60 days; sometimes 90 days.
- **Negotiate**: shorter period (30 days preferred); right to continue conversations with existing investors / co-leads.
- **Negotiate**: termination clause if lead doesn't move (e.g., "exclusivity ends if no draft DSA within 21 days").

### Expense reimbursement
- Lead investor's legal fees reimbursed by company.
- Standard cap: $50K-$100K for seed/Series A; $100K-$200K for Series B+.
- **Negotiate**: cap. If lead pushes uncapped, push back hard. Caps avoid runaway billing.

### Confidentiality
- Term sheet itself is confidential between parties.
- **Negotiate**: founder right to disclose to existing investors / counsel / advisors.
- **Negotiate**: founder right to disclose round close in announcement (after closing).

### Conditions to closing
- Specific conditions that must be met before close:
  - Definitive agreements signed
  - Customary diligence completed
  - Founder vesting agreements signed
  - IP assignments signed
  - 409A valuation completed
  - Investor consents (existing preferred)
- **Negotiate**: clear, defined conditions; not "any condition deemed material by investor"

### MFN among investors
- Side-letters: each investor sometimes signs side-letter with custom terms (special information rights, special pro-rata terms, etc.)
- MFN: if one investor's side-letter has more favorable terms, others get those terms too.
- Standard for early-stage rounds.

## Negotiation sequence — what to fight for first

Founders typically negotiate term sheets in 1-3 rounds of comments. Prioritize.

### Tier 1 (must-fight, dollar-impact, control-impact)
1. **Liquidation preference > 1x** — if anything > 1x non-participating, fight hard
2. **Full ratchet anti-dilution** — fight to weighted-average broad-based
3. **ESOP top-up size** — argue for actual hire-plan need, not generic 10-15%
4. **Founder vesting reset** — credit for time served; not start-from-scratch
5. **Cumulative dividends** — change to non-cumulative or zero
6. **Board composition** — common majority or 50/50 with friendly independent

### Tier 2 (significant, but more negotiable)
7. **Drag-along threshold** — protect founders against forced low exits
8. **Protective provisions list** — narrow the list, especially budget approval
9. **No-shop period** — shorter (30 days) and with clear escape clause
10. **Pro-rata sunset** — limit to next 1-2 rounds
11. **Non-compete duration** — 1 year, narrow geographic scope

### Tier 3 (cleanup, low-leverage)
12. **Expense reimbursement cap** — keep capped
13. **Information rights granularity** — keep reasonable
14. **Confidentiality carve-outs** — preserve founder disclosure rights

### Tier 4 (concede if needed)
15. **D&O insurance** (standard, just budget for it)
16. **Pay-to-play** (rare; concede if lead insists)
17. **Conversion provisions** (standard 1:1)

## Negotiation tactics

### What works
- **Real competing term sheet**: highest leverage. If you have two term sheets, surface them clearly.
- **Counsel-led negotiation**: founder counsel handles redlines; founder handles relationship and final calls.
- **Anchor with specific asks**: don't say "we'd like better terms"; say "1x non-participating; 5% ESOP top-up; founder vesting credits 24 months served."
- **Reasonable concessions**: don't fight every term. Concede tier 4 items to win tier 1.
- **Time-pressure when leverage is real**: if you have a deadline (other term sheet expiry, fundraise close), use it.

### What doesn't work
- **Threats without follow-through**: "We'll walk away" only works if you would actually walk
- **Emotional reactions**: stay process-oriented; emotions read as desperate
- **Negotiating to the death on every term**: counsel will charge you, lead will get annoyed, deal can die
- **Hiding facts from counsel**: counsel can't help if they don't know the full picture

### Counsel coordination
- Brief counsel: "These are my priorities. These are my walk-aways. These are my concedes."
- Don't let counsel negotiate every term; expensive and counterproductive
- Founder owns the relationship with the lead investor

## Common predator clauses to watch for

- **Participating preferred**: investor gets money back AND share of common pro-rata. Double-dip. Avoid.
- **Full ratchet anti-dilution**: devastating in down-rounds. Avoid.
- **Founder vesting reset**: investor wants founders to start vesting from term sheet date. Negotiate credits.
- **Cumulative dividends**: 8%+ accumulating preferred dividends. Avoid; aim for 0% or non-cumulative.
- **Senior preferred over earlier rounds**: investor wants to be paid before earlier investors at exit. Negotiate pari-passu.
- **Indefinite drag-along applies to common**: founders can be dragged into unfavorable sale. Negotiate threshold and floor protection.
- **Approval rights over annual budget**: investor effectively controls strategy. Negotiate to not unreasonably withheld.
- **Expense reimbursement uncapped**: investor counsel runs up bill. Negotiate cap.
- **Founder non-compete > 2 years**: harms founder optionality. Negotiate to 1 year max.
- **No-shop > 60 days**: too much time without competing tension. Negotiate to 30 days or with escape clause.

## Specific scenarios

### Down-round / bridge financing
- Term sheet customs are different. Investors push for stronger preferences, full-ratchet anti-dilution, pay-to-play.
- **Negotiate**: try to maintain 1x preference; accept full ratchet only if absolutely no alternative; refuse senior to all earlier investors (pari-passu only).
- **Consider**: "structured" round (cleanup of existing preferred); recap; SAFE bridge.

### Multiple co-leads
- Two investors leading equal portions. Term sheet terms apply equally.
- **Negotiate**: both leads on board? One lead, one observer? Avoid both leads getting board seats.

### Strategic / corporate VC
- Strategic VC term sheets sometimes include unusual provisions:
  - ROFR on company sale (corporate gets right to buy company first if sold)
  - Consent rights on partnerships with competitors
  - Exclusive distribution agreements
- **Negotiate hard**: these provisions can scare off future investors and acquirers.

### Down-round with co-investor support
- Existing investors invest pro-rata. Apply pay-to-play structure if needed.
- **Negotiate**: align all co-investors on terms before lead negotiation.

### Founder secondary cash carve-out
- Founders sell partial stake at the round (10-20% of founder shares).
- Standard at Series B+; possible at Series A with strong leverage.
- **Negotiate**: amount, who buys (lead or other co-investor), whether structured at round price.

## Output to founder

After diagnostic, produce:

1. **Stage-appropriate context** (what's "standard" at this stage)
2. **Clause-by-clause review** of the term sheet, with negotiation priority (tier 1-4)
3. **Specific redline asks** to bring to counsel (not "negotiate these terms" but "ask for specific change in clause X")
4. **Counter-offer language** for the most contested terms
5. **Walk-away criteria** (specific terms below which the deal isn't worth it)
6. **Counsel briefing summary** (1-page founder-priorities document for counsel)
7. **Process plan** (no-shop period management, communication cadence with lead, target close date)
8. **Post-term-sheet to-close checklist** (vesting agreements, IP assignments, 409A, definitive docs)
9. **What to celebrate post-close**: real signals the round is good vs. just done

The term sheet is where the next 5-10 years of founder-investor relationship is set. Most first-time founders accept terms they later regret because they didn't know the difference between "standard" and "predatory". This coach closes that knowledge gap, clause by clause, so the founder negotiates from understanding instead of from anxiety.

_meta.json Metadata

{
  "ownerId": "kn7d5eszdfwftk153ymhdm4qhs83qsqy",
  "publishedAt": 1778115720367,
  "slug": "term-sheet-negotiation-coach",
  "version": "1.0.0"
}